Paper Evaluation Form

  • CONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS ONLY FOR THE EDITOR

    This information will not be conveyed to author(s). The paper will be accepted for publication after addressing the reviewers comments.
  • With regard to the content of the paper, reviewers should consider the originality and technical correctness of the material, the clarity, and conciseness of the presentation, the appropriateness of the examples (if applicable), and the potential usefulness of the paper to the profession.
    Reviewers also may consider the following in their critiques: keywords, abstract, scope, the purpose of the paper, summary, conclusions, acknowledgments, and references.
  • CRITIQUE OF MANUSCRIPT TO BE SENT TO AUTHOR(S)

    Reviewers are anonymous to authors. Your name will be omitted from the copy of the review form sent to authors.
    Use a professional approach in your comments-they should be aimed at assisting the author(s).
    Be as specific as possible in your comments.
    Wherever possible, reference your comments to marked sections in the manuscript.
    Therefore, please type reviews whenever possible.
  • Max. file size: 36 MB.